Review of San Francisco Ballet’s Production of “Giselle” - 19 February 2008 - San Francisco Opera House
San Francisco Ballet Artistic Director Helgi Tomasson’s production of “Giselle” is classic mythological story-telling in its highest form. A romantic ballet invoking supernatural powers to express unattainable love, perfection and beauty, Tomasson’s “Giselle” captivates the heart and reaches new heights of dance performance.
Giselle is story of a young peasant girl who falls in love with a strange young man, who is secretly a prince and engaged to a noble woman, the realization of which causes Giselle to go mad and die, and the men who loved her to be haunted by the tragedy of her young death.
Maria Kochetkova was exquisite as Giselle, a role that seemed created just for her and her innocent petite persona. On her opening night in San Francisco as Giselle, Kochetkova effortlessly flitting across the stage like a hummingbird, never seeming to touch the ground. Although a young dancer, Kochetkova demonstrated “old school” Russian technique with the high level of technical skill she brings to a performance.
Anita Paciotti as Giselle’s mother, worries about her daughter’s strong passion for dancing. She warns Giselle that she will become one of the “Wilis”, those girls who died before their wedding day that are forced to spend eternity dancing. The “Wilis” myth is fascinating: the beautiful but soulless dancing girls who tempt men into their demise under the moonlight.
Katito Waldo, as “Myrtha the Queen of the Wilis”, who appears after Giselle’s death to initiate her into the Wilis sisterhood, projected a strong and cool queen. Waldo’s Myrtha was smooth and controlled, without the warmth of a mortal. The vivid scenery of the moon-lit forest felt other-worldly, as Waldo led the 24 other Wilis, dressed in all-white bridal gowns and veils, in a ghostly dance above the lake as they floated in arabesque.
Pascal Molat shone as “Hilarion”, Giselle’s other suitor, the Bad Boy, always lurking behind the scenes and frequently brandishing his sword, — but sincere in his affection for the village maiden. One of the ballet’s most intense moments was when the dominating Queen Myrtha commands Hilarion to dance to his death and casts him in the lake. Expressive of a broad range of emotions, Molat’s acting skills are on par with his extraordinary dancing, making him one of the most fascinating character actors in the San Francisco Ballet.
The pas de deux in Act II between Giselle and the Prince, performed by Joan Boada, was another delight. Boada’s princely carriage and muscular legs supported Kochetkova in a series of daring fast spins while she balanced on pointe. Boada looked like a giant next to the tiny Russian who seemed light as a feather as he lifted her progressively higher into the air.
But even as Giselle and the upright Prince danced joyfully around in their merriment, we can’t help but wonder, “where is that Bad Boy, Hilarion, and his sword?”
Perhaps the ballet’s most tragic figure is Hilarion, who gets a raw deal for his affection: death. After all, it was “Mr. Perfect Prince” who was the two-timing playboy. Although less refined than the Prince and guilty of jealousy, Hilarion was a man of genuine feeling, and concern that his fair maiden was being deceived by a stranger.
“Giselle” demonstrates that through dance we can convey complex emotions like jealousy and betrayal and higher ideals like redemption and justice.
Every time I see this ballet, the story reveals something new from the different interpretation. I remember Yuan Yuan Tan’s performance last year as Giselle to be perfect (as always), and I especially found the dance where Tan’s Giselle goes mad to be quite compelling. However, given Kochetkova’s tiny, child-like statue, her Giselle seems more true to the story of the ballet and brings a level of believability to the character I hadn’t seen before. I couldn’t help but notice the smallness of Kochetkova’s delicate fingers as she plucked imaginary flower petals while going mad from her lover’s betrayal.
The musical score, composed by Adolphe Adam, is one of ballet’s finest. I was so inspired by the score that I bought the CD of the music in the lobby of the UK Royal Opera Ballet immediately after I saw my first “Giselle” in London.
Several extraordinarily talented choreographers have contributed different parts of the dance over time to create today’s superb production. Although the story is ancient, the ballet premiered at the Paris Opera Ballet in 1841 with its original choreography by Jules Perrot and Jean Coralli. Marius Petipa later made it a classic, and Helgi Tomasson’s refining touches have now elevated this production of “Giselle” as the culmination of 160 years of ballet artistry.
The story of “Giselle” is already rich with metaphor and meaning, but combined with the choreography, staging, and performances of these dancers, Tomasson’s production of this classic ballet takes on mythological proportion.
See also the reviews from Sean Martinfield and Rachel Howard.